Lined vs. Unlined vs. Underlayer: Choosing the Right Glove for Every Season

When it comes to leather gloves, not all are created equal. At Sullivan Glove, we craft each pair with purpose—whether that’s the raw tactility of unlined leather, the comfort of a lined interior, or the adaptability of an underlayer system. Knowing the difference can help you choose the right glove for your lifestyle, work, or riding season.

Unlined Gloves: Pure Feel & Flexibility

Unlined gloves are all about connection. With no extra material between your hand and the leather, you get maximum dexterity and a true feel for whatever you’re holding—whether it’s handlebars, tools, or a steering wheel. They’re breathable, lightweight, and break in beautifully, molding to your hand over time. Perfect for warmer months or year-round use if you prefer that direct leather-to-skin experience.

Best for: Motorcycling in spring/summer, driving, everyday wear, or any task that demands grip and precision.

And don’t overlook the leather itself. Deer and elk hides are surprisingly warm on their own. Like a dry suit, they trap warmth and insulate better than you might expect, making unlined versions of these leathers excellent transitional-season gloves. (Maybe link here?)

Lined Gloves: Comfort & Warmth

When temperatures drop, a lined glove becomes your best friend. Linings can range from soft fleece to wool or thermal insulation, adding warmth without sacrificing too much dexterity. Lined gloves also provide extra comfort, making them ideal for long rides in the cold or outdoor work in chilly conditions.

Explore our wool-lined and insulated gloves for cold-weather comfort without compromising Sullivan’s craftsmanship.

Best for: Cold-weather riding, winter driving, and keeping hands warm during outdoor work or leisure.

Underlayer System: Versatility & Adaptability

Sometimes one glove can’t do it all. That’s where an underlayer system comes in. By wearing a thin, removable liner (like silk or wool) underneath your unlined gloves, you get the best of both worlds: the feel and flexibility of unlined leather with the added insulation when you need it. This setup lets you adjust for changing conditions without investing in multiple pairs.

Our wool gloves are perfect as an underlayer. In fact, you can see them in action in the photo where we pair them under our Saddle Tan Deerskin gloves—a versatile combination for year-round riding.

Best for: Riders who travel through varying climates, outdoor workers needing flexibility, and anyone who values year-round versatility.

Which Should You Choose?

It comes down to how—and where—you’ll be using your gloves:

• If you value feel and freedom, go unlined.

• If warmth and comfort are non-negotiable, go lined.

• If you want adaptability, pair unlined gloves with a wool underlayer for a flexible, all-seasons solution.

At Sullivan Glove, we design for real-world use, blending heritage craftsmanship with modern needs. Whether lined, unlined, or paired with an underlayer, every glove is built to last so you can choose what works best and wear them for years to come.

Whatever leather you choose, make sure you waterproof them as they are naturally water-resistant, not waterproof. We recommend our balm.